Disc 1

1. Wise Men Blues - Pat Donohue with the Guy's All-Star Shoe Band (Richard Dworsky, Andy Stein, Gary Raynor, Arnie Kinsella.) 12/22/01
2. Bebopareebop Rhubarb Pie - Tim Russell and others 12/12/98
3. Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairies - Sonos Handbell Ensemble 12/21/96
4. A Child Is Born In Bethlehem - Garrison Keillor and Musica Sacra 12/21/02
5. Count Your Blessings - John McDonough
6. Away in a Manger - Renée Fleming and Emanuel Ax (Fred Hersch) 12/20/03
7. The Twelve Days of Christmas - Garrison Keillor and Tom Keith 12/18/04
8. Christmas Eve Morning Blues - Pat Donohue with the Guy's All-Star Shoe Band (Richard Dworsky, Andy Stein, Gary Raynor, Arnie Kinsella) 12/20/03
9. Guy Noir - Garrison Keillor and cast 12/11/04
10. Christmastime (Just In Time) - Inga Swearingen 12/18/04
11. The Christmas Fire - Garrison Keillor 12/09/00
12. Silent Night - Butch Thompson 12/13/03

Disc 2

1. Christmas Time's A-Comin' - Ricky Skaggs and Kentucky Thunder (Mark Fain, bass; Jim Mills, banjo; Paul Brewster, guitar; Darrin Vincent, guitar; Clay Hess, guitar; and Bobby Hicks, fiddle.) 12/16/00
2. `Twas the Night Before Christmas - Garrison Keillor and Richard Dworsky 12/23/00
3. Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas - Diana Krall 12/13/97
4. Santa, CEO 12/28/02
5. The Christmas Song - Sarah Jessica Parker 12/19/98
6. The Christ Child's Lullaby - The Boys of the Lough: Aly Bain (fiddle), Dave Richardson (mandolin, cittern, English concertina, and button accordion), Christy O'Leary (tin whistle, pipes, vocals), Cathal McConnell (flute, whistle, vocals), and Chris Newman (guitar). 12/21/96
7. The Carolers at My Door - The Orianas Choir (or the Buffalo Chamber singers) 12/21/91
8. Green - 12/20/03
9. December Waltz - Pat Donohue National Steel (?) with The Guy's All-Star Shoe Band (Richard Dworsky, John Niemann, Gary Raynor, Arnie Kinsella) 12/4/04
10. In the Bleak Midwinter - Musica Sacra 12/21/02
11. Ave Maria - Renée Fleming and Emanuel Ax (Fred Hersch) 12/20/03
12. Four Christmases - Garrison Keillor
13. Let It Snow, Let It Snow, Let It Snow - April Verch, fiddle 12/22/01
14. Silent Night - 12/21/02